郭天民, 钟银珠, 李再琮. The Application and Comparison of Four Activity Coefficient Models in Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium and Distillation Calculations[J]. CIESC Journal, 1980, (2).
郭天民, 钟银珠, 李再琮. The Application and Comparison of Four Activity Coefficient Models in Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium and Distillation Calculations[J]. CIESC Journal, 1980, (2).DOI:
The four well-known activity coefficient models (Wilson
NKTL
McCann and UN1FAC)
coupled with virial equation and tridiagonal matrix method
have been successfully applied to the vigorous computation of various non-ideal distillation processes. The N1DISTL program developed by authors has been tested for 33 distillation systems
with more than on hundred calculations performed. To make a parallel comparison of these activity coefficient models
18 sets of binary vapor-liquid equilibrium data were chosen
each set was fitted to Wilson
NRTL and McCann equations respectively by using non-linear least square technique. The binary parameters so determined were used to predict the bubble point equilibrium data of 18 binary and 8 derived multicomponent systems. The predictions of four models were compared with experimental data. To illustrate the consistency of distillation calculation results using different activity coefficient models
four examples were presented. The temperature
flow rate and composition profiles calculated were compared and the cause of discrepancy in some cases were discussed.