1.中国科学院过程工程研究所介科学与过程工程全国重点实验室,北京 100190
2.中国科学院大学化学工程学院, 北京 100049
张华海(1995—),男,博士,青年研究员,hhzhang@ipe.ac.cn
王利民(1979—),男,博士,研究员,lmwang@ipe.ac.cn
收稿:2026-02-28,
修回:2026-04-08,
录用:2026-04-09,
纸质出版:2026-10-25
移动端阅览
张华海, 张楠, 王利民. 基于EMMS的混相模型用于气固流化床高效模拟[J]. 化工学报, 2026, 77(10): 5739-5753
ZHANG Huahai, ZHANG Nan, WANG Limin. EMMS-based mixture model for high-efficiency simulations of gas-solid fluidized beds[J]. CIESC Journal, 2026, 77(10): 5739-5753
张华海, 张楠, 王利民. 基于EMMS的混相模型用于气固流化床高效模拟[J]. 化工学报, 2026, 77(10): 5739-5753 DOI: 10.11949/0438-1157.20260268.
ZHANG Huahai, ZHANG Nan, WANG Limin. EMMS-based mixture model for high-efficiency simulations of gas-solid fluidized beds[J]. CIESC Journal, 2026, 77(10): 5739-5753 DOI: 10.11949/0438-1157.20260268.
气固流化床由于其优良的气固接触效率和传热传质效率,被广泛应用于化工、能源等领域。但其复杂的时空非线性多尺度结构导致设计和放大困难。目前广泛应用于工业尺度模拟的软件内嵌数值方法为连续介质模型,包括双流体模型(TFM)和混相模型(mixture model),但是传统模型在计算速度和精度上仍然和实际过程有较大差距。双流体模型中气固相间作用过于复杂,需要求解大量的微分方程并且编码困难。混相模型通过求解混合物方程和气固两相滑移速度代数方程模拟两相流动,与双流体模型相比控制方程减少一半,在稳定性和计算效率上更具优势。但是,传统的连续介质模型假设单元网格内颗粒均匀分布,导致气固两相滑移速度计算不准确。因此,气固流化床的三维模拟仍然存在计算成本巨大以及精度低的问题,难以近实时地准确模拟工业规模流化床反应器。本工作基于能量最小多尺度(EMMS)原理,明晰了气固流化床反应器中两相滑移速度的形成机制,并建立了定量的介尺度滑移速度模型。随后,将EMMS模型对气固介尺度结构的解析能力与混相模型对宏观多相流动的描述能力相结合,利用EMMS直接求解的滑移速度来封闭混相模型,由此构建了基于EMMS的混相模型。将该模型用于三维含Geldart A类颗粒的鼓泡流化床、湍动流化床和快速流化床反应器以及全回路流化床反应器的数值模拟。结果表明,该模型能够很好地捕捉流化床中的介尺度结构以及快速流化床中的气固“环-核”结构和“S型”空隙率分布;且该模型预测的时均轴向颗粒浓度分布与实验数据吻合良好。与传统双流体模型相比,该模型在维持同等精度的同时,允许使用0.1 s的大时间步长,从而实现了大规模流化床反应器的快速模拟(加速比达300倍以上)。综上,基于EMMS的混相模型实现了对含Geldart A类颗粒的三维鼓泡、湍动及快速流化床的快速准确模拟,为工业循环气固流化床反应器的工程放大及运行优化提供了可靠的理论依据。
Gas-solid fluidized beds are widely used in chemical
energy
and other fields due to their excellent gas-solid contact efficiency and heat and mass transfer efficiency. However
their complex spatio temporal nonlinear multiscale makes design and scale-up difficult. Currently
the numerical methods embedded in software widely used for industrial-scale simulations are continuum models
including the two fluid model (TFM) and the mixture model. However
traditional models still exhibit significant gaps in computational speed and accuracy compared to actual processes. In the TFM
gas-solid interphase interactions are overly complex
requiring the solution of numerous differential equations and presenting coding difficulties. The mixture model simulates two-phase flow by solving mixture equations and algebraic equations for the gas-solid slip velocity. Compared to the TFM
the number of governing equations is halved
offering greater advantages in model stability and computational efficiency. However
traditional continuum models assume a uniform particle distribution within grid cells
leading to inaccurate calculations of the gas-solid slip velocity. Therefore
three-dimensional simulations of gas-solid fluidized beds still suffer from massive computational costs and low accuracy
making it difficult to accurately simulate industrial-scale fluidized bed reactors in near real-time. In this work
based on the energy-minimization multi-scale (EMMS) principle
the formation mechanism of the two-phase slip velocity in gas-solid fluidized bed reactors is elucidated
and a quantitative mesoscale slip velocity model is established. Subsequently
by combining the resolution capability of the EMMS model for gas-solid mesoscale structures with the descriptive capability of the mixture model for macroscopic multiphase flows
the mixture model is closed using the slip velocity directly solved by the EMMS. Thus
an EMMS-based mixture model is constructed. This model is applied to the numerical simulations of three-dimensional bubbling
turbulent
and fast fluidized bed reactors containing Geldart A particles
as well as full-loop fluidized bed reactors. Numerical results show that the model can successfully capture the mesoscale structures in fluidized beds
along with the gas-solid “core-annulus” structure and “S-shaped” voidage distribution in fast fluidized beds. The results demonstrate that the time-averaged axial particle concentration distribution predicted by the model aligns well with experimental data. Compared with the traditional TFM
this model maintains comparable accuracy while allowing the use of a large time step of 0.1 s
thereby achieving the rapid simulation of large-scale fluidized bed reactors (with a speedup ratio of over 300 times). In summary
the EMMS-based mixture model enables fast and accurate three-dimensional simulations of bubbling
turbulent
and fast fluidized beds containing Geldart A particles
providing a reliable theoretical basis for the engineering scale-up and operational optimization of industrial circulating gas-solid fluidized bed reactors.
Zapater D , Kulkarni S R , Wery F , et al . Multifunctional fluidized bed reactors for process intensification [J ] . Progress in Energy and Combustion Science , 2024 , 105 : 101176 .
Alobaid F , Almohammed N , Massoudi Farid M , et al . Progress in CFD simulations of fluidized beds for chemical and energy process engineering [J ] . Progress in Energy and Combustion Science , 2022 , 91 : 100930 .
Chew J W , LaMarche W C Q , Cocco R A . 100 years of scaling up fluidized bed and circulating fluidized bed reactors [J ] . Powder Technology , 2022 , 409 : 117813 .
Zhao Z J , Zhou L , Bai L , et al . Recent advances and perspectives of CFD-DEM simulation in fluidized bed [J ] . Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering , 2024 , 31 ( 2 ): 871 - 918 .
Deng B Y , Zhang Y , Zhang M , et al . Identification and dynamic properties of clusters for Geldart group B particles in a circulating fluidized bed [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2022 , 248 : 117265 .
Wang H F , Chen Y P , Wang W . Particle-level dynamics of clusters: experiments in a gas-fluidized bed [J ] . AIChE Journal , 2022 , 68 ( 3 ): e17525 .
Wu G P , Yang X , He Y . Experimental exploration of particle cluster characteristics in the gas-solid diameter-varying fluidized bed [J ] . Powder Technology , 2023 , 429 : 118948 .
Li A J , Zhu L Y , Zhu X L , et al . Particle scale modeling of heat transfer between mesoscale clusters and surfaces in fluidized beds [J ] . Case Studies in Thermal Engineering , 2024 , 60 : 104634 .
Li A J , Li X Y , Xu X G , et al . Numerical modeling of wall-to-cluster heat transfer in swirling fluidized beds based on MFiX-DEM approach [J ] . Case Studies in Thermal Engineering , 2025 , 65 : 105634 .
Zhu H Y , Zhu J , Li G Z , et al . Detailed measurements of flow structure inside a dense gas–solids fluidized bed [J ] . Powder Technology , 2008 , 180 ( 3 ): 339 - 349 .
Aghbashlo M , Sotudeh-Gharebagh R , Zarghami R , et al . Measurement techniques to monitor and control fluidization quality in fluidized bed dryers: a review [J ] . Drying Technology , 2014 , 32 ( 9 ): 1005 - 1051 .
Zhu X L , Xu Y , Tu Q Y , et al . Advanced measurement techniques for gas-solids fluidized beds in the power and energy industry — a review [J ] . Measurement: Energy , 2024 , 4 : 100030 .
Ma H Q , Liu Z H , Zhou L Y , et al . Numerical investigation of the particle flow behaviors in a fluidized-bed drum by CFD-DEM [J ] . Powder Technology , 2023 , 429 : 118891 .
Ma Z Y , Tu Q Y , Liu Z X , et al . CFD-DEM investigation of the gas-solid flow characteristics in a fluidized bed dryer [J ] . Chemical Engineering Research and Design , 2023 , 196 : 235 - 253 .
Tu Q Y , Ma Z Y , Wang H G . Investigation of wet particle drying process in a fluidized bed dryer by CFD simulation and experimental measurement [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2023 , 452 : 139200 .
de Munck M J A , Peters E A J F , Kuipers J A M . CFD-DEM modeling and validation of solids drying in a gas-fluidized bed [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2024 , 291 : 119922 .
Alipoor M , Kazemi S , Zarghami R , et al . CFD-DEM Investigation of the effects of particle size and fluidization regime on heat transfer in fluidized beds [J ] . Computational Particle Mechanics , 2025 , 12 ( 4 ): 2037 - 2058 .
Khodabandehlou R , Norouzi H R , Larimi A , et al . Analysis of biomass gasification in a fluidized bed using CFD-DEM [J ] . Energy , 2025 , 320 : 135395 .
Wang J W . Continuum theory for dense gas-solid flow: a state-of-the-art review [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2020 , 215 : 115428 .
He Y R , Ren A X , Tang T Q , et al . Multi-scale numerical simulation of flow, heat and mass transfer behaviors in dense gas-solid flows: a brief review [J ] . Journal of Thermal Science , 2022 , 31 ( 3 ): 607 - 633 .
Wang W , Lu B N , Zhang N , et al . A review of multiscale CFD for gas-solid CFB modeling [J ] . International Journal of Multiphase Flow , 2010 , 36 ( 2 ): 109 - 118 .
Wang S , Hu C S , Luo K , et al . Multi-scale numerical simulation of fluidized beds: model applicability assessment [J ] . Particuology , 2023 , 80 : 11 - 41 .
Alobaid F , Ströhle J , Epple B . Extended CFD/DEM model for the simulation of circulating fluidized bed [J ] . Advanced Powder Technology , 2013 , 24 ( 1 ): 403 - 415 .
Ku X K , Li T , Løvås T . CFD–DEM simulation of biomass gasification with steam in a fluidized bed reactor [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2015 , 122 : 270 - 283 .
Ostermeier P , DeYoung S , Vandersickel A , et al . Comprehensive investigation and comparison of TFM, DenseDPM and CFD-DEM for dense fluidized beds [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2019 , 196 : 291 - 309 .
Wang S , Luo K , Hu C S , et al . CFD-DEM simulation of heat transfer in fluidized beds: model verification, validation, and application [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2019 , 197 : 280 - 295 .
Xie J , Zhong W Q , Shao Y J , et al . Coupling of CFD-DEM and reaction model for 3D fluidized beds [J ] . Powder Technology , 2019 , 353 : 72 - 83 .
Wang Z K , Liu M B . Semi-resolved CFD-DEM for thermal particulate flows with applications to fluidized beds [J ] . International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 2020 , 159 : 120150 .
Wang S , Shen Y S . CFD-DEM study of thermal behaviours of chip-like particles flow in a fluidized bed [J ] . Powder Technology , 2024 , 445 : 120066 .
Jiang F , Liu H H , Chen X , et al . A coupled LBM-DEM method for simulating the multiphase fluid-solid interaction problem [J ] . Journal of Computational Physics , 2022 , 454 : 110963 .
Fu S T , Wang L M . GPU-based unresolved LBM-DEM for fast simulation of gas-solid flows [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2023 , 465 : 142898 .
Liu Y G , Zhao B D , Xu J , et al . A TFM-IBM method for Cartesian grid simulation of gas-solid flows in complex geometries [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2025 , 312 : 121637 .
Prajapati C , Nadda M , Singh K , et al . Artificial neural network-based EMMS drag model for fluidized beds [J ] . Powder Technology , 2025 , 465 : 121217 .
Zhao Y M , Yuan S Z , Chen X , et al . A Stokes number-dependent filtered drag model for fluidized gas-particle beds with varying material properties [J ] . Powder Technology , 2025 , 457 : 120860 .
Wang H , Lu Y J . 3D simulations of voidage distribution in SCW fluidized beds using the EMMS model [J ] . Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research , 2022 , 61 ( 36 ): 13720 - 13733 .
Geng J W , Tian Y J , Wang W . Exploring a unified EMMS drag model for gas-solid fluidization [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2022 , 251 : 117444 .
Ouyang B , Zhu L T , Luo Z H . Data-driven modeling of mesoscale solids stress closures for filtered two-fluid model in gas-particle flows [J ] . AIChE Journal , 2021 , 67 ( 7 ): e17290 .
Boniou V , Fox R O . Shock-particle-curtain-interaction study with a hyperbolic two-fluid model: effect of particle force models [J ] . International Journal of Multiphase Flow , 2023 , 169 : 104591 .
Stroh A , Alobaid F , Busch J P , et al . 3-D numerical simulation for co-firing of torrefied biomass in a pulverized-fired 1 MW th combustion chamber [J ] . Energy , 2015 , 85 : 105 - 116 .
Goda H , Hibiki T , Kim S , et al . Drift-flux model for downward two-phase flow [J ] . International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 2003 , 46 ( 25 ): 4835 - 4844 .
Shi H , Holmes J A , Durlofsky L J , et al . Drift-flux modeling of two-phase flow in wellbores [J ] . SPE Journal , 2005 , 10 ( 1 ): 24 - 33 .
Ozaki T , Hibiki T . Drift-flux model for rod bundle geometry [J ] . Progress in Nuclear Energy , 2015 , 83 : 229 - 247 .
Hibiki T , Tsukamoto N . Drift-flux model for upward dispersed two-phase flows in a vertical rod bundle [J ] . Applied Thermal Engineering , 2023 , 226 : 120323 .
Hibiki T , Tsukamoto N . Drift-flux model for upward dispersed two-phase flows in vertical medium-to-large round tubes [J ] . Progress in Nuclear Energy , 2023 , 158 : 104611 .
蒋鸣 , 周强 . 气固流化床介尺度结构形成机制及过滤曳力模型研究进展 [J ] . 化工学报 , 2022 , 73 ( 6 ): 2468 - 2485 .
Jiang M , Zhou Q . Progress on mechanisms of mesoscale structures and mesoscale drag model in gas-solid fluidized beds [J ] . CIESC Journal , 2022 , 73 ( 6 ): 2468 - 2485 .
Li J H , Kwauk M . Particle-Fluid Two-Phase Flow: the Energy-Minimization Multi-Scale Method [M ] . Beijing : Metallurgical Industry Press , 1994 .
Shang Z , Lou J , Li H Y . CFD of dilute gas-solid two-phase flow using Lagrangian algebraic slip mixture model [J ] . Powder Technology , 2014 , 266 : 120 - 128 .
Jiang Y , Lan Y . A dynamic mixture model for non-equilibrium multiphase fluids [J ] . Computer Graphics Forum , 2021 , 40 ( 7 ): 85 - 95 .
Li J H , Ge W , Wang W , et al . Focusing on mesoscales: from the energy-minimization multiscale model to mesoscience [J ] . Current Opinion in Chemical Engineering , 2016 , 13 : 10 - 23 .
Qin Z Y , Zhou Q , Wang J W . An EMMS drag model for coarse grid simulation of polydisperse gas-solid flow in circulating fluidized bed risers [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2019 , 207 : 358 - 378 .
Qiu X P , Wang L M , Yang N , et al . A simplified two-fluid model coupled with EMMS drag for gas-solid flows [J ] . Powder Technology , 2017 , 314 : 299 - 314 .
Hu S W , Liu X H . 3D CFD-PBM simulation of gas-solid bubbling beds of Geldart A particles with sub-grid drag correction [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2023 , 275 : 118660 .
Meng L Y , Zhang X J , Shang Y Q , et al . A simplified steady-state mesoscale drag model with an analytical solution for fluidized beds [J ] . Powder Technology , 2023 , 429 : 118955 .
Zhang X K , Tian Y J , Lu B N , et al . A multiscale interphase heat transfer model for fluidized beds based on the steady-state EMMS approach [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2024 , 298 : 120408 .
Zhang L B , Ma Y L , Liu M Y . Numerical simulations of gas-liquid-solid circulating flows coupled to mesoscale parameters and measurements [J ] . Particuology , 2025 , 97 : 236 - 256 .
Hu S W , Liu X H . CFD-PBM simulation of gas-solid bubbling flow with structure-dependent drag coefficients [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2021 , 413 : 127503 .
Hu S W , Liu X H . A simple and general sub-grid drag model for gas-solid fast fluidization [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2021 , 421 : 129922 .
Zhu L T , Lei H , Ouyang B , et al . Using mesoscale drag model-augmented coarse-grid simulation to design fluidized bed reactor: effect of bed internals and sizes [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2022 , 253 : 117547 .
Zhang H H , Wang L M . Dynamic energy-minimization multi-scale heterogeneous continuum evolution model for gas-solid fluidization [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2024 , 480 : 148343 .
Manninen M , Taivassalo V , Kallio S . On the mixture model for multiphase flow [J ] . VTT Publications , 1996 : 288 .
Gidaspow D , Bezburuah R , Ding J . Hydrodynamics of circulating fluidized beds: kinetic theory approach [C ] // Proceedings of the 7th Engineering Foundation Conference on Fluidization , 1992 : 75 - 82 .
Schaeffer D G . Instability in the evolution equations describing incompressible granular flow [J ] . Journal of Differential Equations , 1987 , 66 ( 1 ): 19 - 50 .
Lun C K K , Savage S B , Jeffrey D J , et al . Kinetic theories for granular flow: inelastic particles in Couette flow and slightly inelastic particles in a general flowfield [J ] . Journal of Fluid Mechanics , 1984 , 140 : 223 - 256 .
Ding J M , Gidaspow D . A bubbling fluidization model using kinetic theory of granular flow [J ] . AIChE Journal , 1990 , 36 ( 4 ): 523 - 538 .
Zhang H H , Sun P J , Wang L M . Dynamic energy-minimization multi-scale evolution model for three-dimensional simulation of gas-solid fluidized beds with Geldart A particles [J ] . Chemical Engineering Science , 2025 , 317 : 122004 .
Luo H , Lu B N , Zhang J Y , et al . A grid-independent EMMS/bubbling drag model for bubbling and turbulent fluidization [J ] . Chemical Engineering Journal , 2017 , 326 : 47 - 57 .
Dubrawski K , Tebianian S , Bi H T , et al . Traveling column for comparison of invasive and non-invasive fluidization voidage measurement techniques [J ] . Powder Technology , 2013 , 235 : 203 - 220 .
Venderbosch R H . The role of clusters in gas-solids reactors: an experimental study [D ] . Enschede : University of Twente , 1998 .
Wu Y Y , Peng L , Qin L Q , et al . Validation and application of CPFD models in simulating hydrodynamics and reactions in riser reactor with Geldart A particles [J ] . Powder Technology , 2018 , 323 : 269 - 283 .
Zhang N , Lu B N , Wang W , et al . Virtual experimentation through 3D full-loop simulation of a circulating fluidized bed [J ] . Particuology , 2008 , 6 ( 6 ): 529 - 539 .
Johnson P C , Jackson R . Frictional-collisional constitutive relations for granular materials, with application to plane shearing [J ] . Journal of Fluid Mechanics , 1987 , 176 : 67 - 93 .
0
浏览量
16
下载量
0
CSCD
关联资源
相关文章
相关作者
相关机构
京公网安备11010102001995号